Government Weighs Intervention as Semiconductor Disruption Fears Grow
The union plans to carry out an 18-day general strike beginning on May 21.
With Samsung Electronics labor-management talks ending in failure, a general strike set for May 21 has become a reality. The strike by Samsung Electronics’ labor union carries consequences serious enough that the government’s top economic official took the unusual step of issuing a public warning. Damage running into the tens of trillions of won is feared, driven by semiconductor production disruptions and supply chain instability.
Koo Yun-cheol, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Economy and Finance, wrote on X (formerly Twitter) on May 13, “The government is deeply saddened that labor-management negotiations at Samsung Electronics have failed to reach an agreement even through post-mediation.” He added, “We will continue supporting resolution through principled negotiations under any circumstances.”
Samsung Electronics’ labor and management had maintained post-mediation talks for 17 hours, from 10:00 a.m. the previous day through the early morning hours of May 13, under the arbitration of the National Labor Relations Commission, but failed to narrow the gap over the bonus system and ultimately collapsed. Management refused to accept the union’s demands for the abolition of bonus caps and for the transparent and institutionalized disclosure of payment criteria.
The union plans to carry out an 18-day general strike beginning on May 21. As of the morning of that day, approximately 42,000 workers had signed up to participate, with the union projecting that a minimum of 50,000 workers would join.
Should the strike materialize, the scale of direct losses would be difficult to comprehend. Analysis suggests that halting factory operations could generate losses of tens of billions of won per minute and approximately 1 trillion won (approximately $680 million) per day. The union’s own internal estimate of production disruption alone is reported to fall between 20 trillion won and 30 trillion won.
The deeper concern lies in what officials are calling “invisible costs.” Shin Je-yun, Chairman of the Samsung Electronics Board of Directors, warned in a message posted to the company’s internal bulletin board: “Should the company’s value decline due to massive strike losses and customer defection, it will inflict serious harm on shareholders, investors, employees, and the local community.” He further cautioned, “Hundreds of billions of dollars in exports and tens of trillions of won in tax revenue would be lost, and the resulting upward pressure on exchange rates would reduce gross domestic product, dealing a severe blow to the national economy.”
Inside and outside the government, speculation is growing over the potential invocation of an emergency adjustment order. The government’s position is cautious. Such orders have been used only in the most extreme circumstances, having been invoked just four times in history: at Korea Shipbuilding Corporation in 1969, at Hyundai Motor Company in 1993, and during the Asiana Airlines and Korean Air pilots’ strikes in 2005.
Given that the semiconductor industry represents a core pillar of South Korea’s economic growth, the government is watching the situation with close attention. Since time still remains before the announced strike date, the possibility of a dramatic last-minute agreement through behind-the-scenes dialogue has not been entirely ruled out. Kang Yu-jeong, Chief Spokesperson for Cheong Wa Dae, conveyed the message that “there is still time remaining” and that the government “will actively support a resolution through dialogue between labor and management.”
In the event the situation deteriorates, some observers suggest that Kim Yeong-hun, Minister of Employment and Labor, may invoke the emergency adjustment order, which restricts industrial action including strikes. However, Minister Kim himself expressed caution, stating that the matter “must be resolved through dialogue.”
The union also believes the likelihood of an emergency adjustment order being invoked is low. A union official at Samsung Electronics stated, “My understanding is that the government’s stance is that we should fight and win this ourselves, and we are fighting by the book,” adding, “We are not considering the possibility of an invocation.” Hong Ji-na, legal counsel for the union, also explained, “The conditions for invoking an emergency adjustment order are extremely strict, and in our case, there is a reasonable argument that we do not qualify as an essential facility.”
Meanwhile, given Samsung Electronics’ outsized presence in the business community, analysts note that the resolution of this bonus dispute will likely influence other companies as well.
In fact, the current bonus controversy was triggered in large part by SK Hynix’s decision to distribute 10% of its operating profit as bonuses with no ceiling. In its wake, the Samsung Electronics union has begun pushing for a similar arrangement, and observers suggest that unions at other companies may follow the same trajectory.
In fact, the Hyundai Motor Company union is already demanding 30% of last year’s net profit as a bonus, while Kakao is also reported to be experiencing painful labor-management friction over issues including the payment of bonuses equivalent to approximately 10% of operating profit.
Samsung Electronics shares, widely held by retail investors and often referred to as the “national stock,” plunged more than 5% in early trading today in the aftermath of the collapsed talks. However, the stock recovered to close up 1.79% compared to the previous trading session, buoyed by the government’s message of active support for labor-management dialogue.
As the strength of semiconductor large-cap stocks continued, the KOSPI index also rose 2.63% to finish at 7844.01, recording an all-time high on a closing price basis.
Jung Suk-yee
댓글
0